What is Andy Stanley’s View of Homosexuality?

“Unconditional” Conference

Andy Stanley’s recent “Unconditional” conference, hosted at North Point Community Church, has garnered significant attention and raised concerns among some conservative Christians regarding his views on homosexuality. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the concerning aspects observed at the conference:

1. Conference Theme and Purpose: The “Unconditional” conference, aimed at parents of LGBTQ+ children and ministry leaders, intended to find a “quieter middle space” on this contentious topic​​. It highlighted a pastoral approach to address the needs of young people in the church experiencing same-sex attraction and parents whose children were coming out to them​​.
2. Stanley’s Approach to Christian Sexual Ethics: Andy Stanley outlined his understanding of Christian sexual ethics with directives that included honoring God with one’s body, not being mastered by anything, and not sexualizing relationships outside of marriage. He affirmed that Biblical marriage is between a man and a woman and that homosexuality is a sin according to the New Testament​​. However, this message was seen as contradictory by some, given the context of the conference​​.
3. Controversial Conference Speakers: Justin Lee and Brian Nietzel, described as “two married gay men” and “Christ-followers,” were invited to speak. Their stories of growing up in church while experiencing same-sex attraction were deemed “instructive and inspiring” by Stanley​​. However, their involvement in same-sex relationships was seen as contradictory to the Biblical definition of marriage and sexual ethics​​.
4. Implications of Speaker Choices: Critics questioned why speakers who grew up in the church, recognized same-sex attraction, but chose to live in obedience to Biblical teachings, weren’t invited instead. The selection of speakers like Lee and Nietzel was viewed as implicitly validating a trajectory toward same-sex relationships​​.
5. Stanley’s Perspective on Same-Sex Marriage: Stanley mentioned that some people choose same-sex marriage for reasons like love, companionship, and family, not because they believe it is biblical. This statement was seen as accepting the premise that chastity is “not sustainable”​​.
6. Response to Homosexuality: Stanley argued that the church’s response should be welcoming, regardless of a person’s past or current circumstances. He framed this approach not as “condoning sin” but as “restoring relationships”​​.
7. Critiques from Conservative Christians: Jeff Johnston, a gender issues analyst, expressed concerns that the conference might mislead attendees about Biblical teachings on homosexuality and gender identity​​. He argued that while the church should love sinners, it should not truncate the Gospel or affirm false identities related to homosexuality and transgenderism​​.
8. Encouraging Repentance and Transformation: Johnston emphasized the power of the Gospel and the Holy Spirit in leading people to repentance, forgiveness, and transformation, suggesting alternative resources for families impacted by these issues​​.

The “Unconditional” conference, through its themes, speaker selection, and Stanley’s own messages, presented a nuanced and somewhat controversial stance on homosexuality, which has led to debate and concern within conservative Christian circles.

More Examples

Here are more examples of Andy Stanley’s statements and actions that have raised concerns about his stance on homosexuality:

1. Sermon on Grace and Truth: In a sermon titled “When Gracie Met Truthy,” Stanley discussed the story of a divorced couple where the husband entered a same-sex relationship. He emphasized the tension between grace and truth, stating that while the truth labels us as sinners, grace does not condemn. The story concluded with the gay couple, along with their extended family, worshipping together at North Point Church. This narrative led some, including Dr. Albert Mohler, to question whether Stanley was only condemning adultery and not the homosexual relationship itself​​.
2. Mixed Messages in Sermons: Pastor Dan Delzell commented that Stanley seemed to send “mixed messages” regarding his stance on homosexuality. Both Mohler and Delzell hoped for clarification from Stanley to affirm the biblical declaration of the sinfulness of homosexual behavior, even as he preaches forgiveness through Christ​​.
3. Avoidance in Sermons: In the final message of an 8-part sermon series, Stanley avoided explicitly addressing the issue of homosexuality. He did not use the words “gay” or “homosexuality” but discussed how Christians are viewed as judgmental and homophobic. He stressed that Christians are called to hold onto both truth and grace, which includes forgiveness and love​​.
4. Praise and Criticism for Statements: Stanley received criticism for asserting that gay churchgoers “have more faith than I do.” He said the LGBTQ+ community is an important and faithful part of the church and encouraged Christians to welcome LGBTQ individuals into churches. He spoke about learning from gay men and women who want to worship God despite not feeling accepted in their formative years​​. There was no mention of repentance in this sermon.

These examples illustrate a pattern in Stanley’s messages where he emphasizes love, inclusion, and grace, which has led to ambiguity about his stance on the biblical view of homosexuality.

Read More

For further reading on the biblical view of homosexuality, consider these four books:

1. “The Bible and Homosexual Practice: Texts and Hermeneutics” by Robert A.J. Gagnon – This book provides a thorough analysis of the biblical texts related to homosexuality and discusses their implications for modern readers.
2. “What Does the Bible Really Teach about Homosexuality?” by Kevin DeYoung – DeYoung explores what Scripture says about homosexuality, addressing key questions and offering a compassionate yet uncompromising response.